When it comes to staffing a medical spa, one of the most important considerations is determining how to compensate your team. Whether you're employing medical professionals, aestheticians, or front desk staff, the structure of your compensation plan can significantly impact your business’s success.
Medspa compensation models often include a mix of flat fees, hourly wages, or commission-based structures - and the choice between these methods depends on various factors, including legal compliance, staff motivation, and business goals.
However, medspa owners must navigate a complex landscape of state and federal regulations, especially when it comes to commission-based compensation. This article explores the pros and cons of different compensation models, with a particular focus on the risks of commission-based pay in medspas and how to structure a legally compliant and motivating compensation plan.
1. Flat Fee vs. Commission-Based Compensation
Before diving into the potential risks and rewards, let’s break down the two primary compensation models seen in medspas: flat fee and commission-based pay.
Flat Fee (Salary or Hourly) Compensation for Med Spa Employees
Flat fee compensation means employees are paid a fixed amount regardless of performance. This model can be either salary or hourly, depending on the role. For example, aestheticians or office staff may receive a set hourly wage, while medical professionals may be salaried.
Pros of Flat Fee Compensation:
- Predictability: Flat fees provide staff with predictable income, which can boost employee morale and reduce turnover.
- Consistency in Cash Flow: The business can better forecast payroll expenses, aiding in budgeting and financial planning.
- Legal Safety: Unlike commission structures, flat fees are more likely to comply with state and federal regulations since they don’t tie pay to patient referrals or the sale of medical services.
Cons of Flat Fee Compensation:
- Potential Lack of Motivation: Staff may feel less incentivized to perform at their highest level, especially if their compensation doesn't reflect the revenue they generate.
- Less Flexibility: Flat fees may not align with a business’s performance-based culture, where employees feel they can directly impact their earnings through effort and results.
Commission-Based Compensation for Med Spa Employees
Commission-based compensation structures typically involve paying employees a percentage of the revenue generated by their work. This model is most common for roles that include a ‘sales’ or ‘referral’ role such as aestheticians, medical practitioners, or front-office staff involved in booking and upselling treatments.
Pros of Commission-Based Compensation:
- Motivation for High Performance: Commission incentivizes employees to perform at their best. Since earnings are tied directly to performance, staff are more likely to work harder to upsell services, increase bookings, or improve patient retention.
- Scalable: Commission-based pay is scalable, meaning businesses can grow without dramatically increasing fixed labor costs. As the business earns more, employees can potentially earn more too.
- Entrepreneurial Spirit: Staff may take ownership of their work, feeling empowered to build their client base, offer additional services, and contribute directly to the business’s success.
Cons of Commission-Based Compensation:
- Legal Risks: The most significant drawback to commission-based compensation in medspas is the potential for legal violations, particularly regarding fee-splitting laws and anti-kickback statutes. Many states prohibit physicians from sharing revenue with non-physician staff, and paying commissions for referrals or medical services can lead to hefty fines and legal trouble.
- Inconsistent Earnings: While commissions can offer the potential for high earnings, the unpredictability of pay can lead to staff stress or dissatisfaction, especially during slow periods or in markets with inconsistent client demand.
- Complexity: Defining your commission rules and tracking commission performance over time can add complexity to your payroll (compared to a more straight-forward hours tracking).
- Potential for Unethical Behavior: Commission-based systems can sometimes incentivize employees to prioritize sales over patient care, leading to upselling or recommending unnecessary treatments, which can damage a medspa’s reputation.
2. Legal Considerations When Paying Commissions
In the realm of medspa operations, it’s crucial to understand the legal landscape surrounding compensation. Medical spas are subject to regulations that differ from traditional spas, particularly when it comes to the way they compensate staff.
Fee-Splitting and Anti-Kickback Laws: Many states have laws that prevent “fee-splitting,” where a physician shares the revenue from medical services with non-physicians. This means that paying commissions to non-medical staff for medical procedures could violate these laws, leading to fines or even suspension of a medical license.
Additionally, anti-kickback laws are designed to prevent compensation for referrals or the sale of unnecessary medical services. For example, paying commissions to employees for referring patients to another provider within the practice for a different treatment could be considered a violation of these laws.
It’s also important to note that any unethical conduct can still be considered a violation of medical board rules, even if a state does not have explicit fee-splitting or anti-kickback regulations. Therefore, medspa owners must be vigilant about ensuring their compensation structures align with the law.
Potential Consequences of Violations of These Statutes:
- Fines: States like California impose substantial fines, up to $50,000, for violations of these laws.
- License Revocation or Suspension: Physicians found guilty of illegal compensation practices may face suspension or even revocation of their medical licenses.
- Damage to Reputation: Legal issues can tarnish your business’s reputation, leading to the loss of clients and difficulty attracting skilled staff.
3. Alternative Compensation Structures to Stay Compliant
While commission-based compensation can be effective, it’s crucial to structure it in a way that complies with state laws. Here are a few alternatives to consider:
- Bonus Structure: Instead of offering commission-based pay, medspas can create a performance-based bonus system that rewards staff based on individual and spa-wide goals, such as customer satisfaction, treatment outcomes, or retail sales.
- Retail Commission: Paying commissions on retail products or non-medical services is generally legal in most states. This allows your staff to still benefit from their sales efforts on certain types of sales, while avoiding potential legal pitfalls around the sale of medical services.
- Profit Sharing or Revenue Sharing: Another alternative is to offer a share of the spa’s profits, either as a fixed amount or percentage, based on the overall performance of the business.
By shifting away from commission for medical services, and instead focusing on bonuses or other incentivized models, medspa owners can maintain compliance while still motivating their team.
4. Creating a Legally Compliant, Motivating Compensation Plan
A successful compensation plan balances legal compliance with employee motivation. Here are a few tips for creating a compensation structure that works for both your staff and your business:
- Consult with Legal Experts: Always consult with an attorney specializing in healthcare and labor laws for your state before implementing a compensation structure. This will help you avoid potential violations.
- Be Transparent: Clearly communicate the compensation model to your staff and ensure they understand how they are paid and what metrics will determine their earnings.
- If you are doing a commission or bonus plan, make sure you think through the nuances ahead of time -
- e.g., do you pay on the full amount collected? Do you include or exclude taxes (most exclude)? Do you include or exclude any applied discounts or special offers on the services (most exclude, but this is more variable)?
- How often are you running the numbers? And how much visibility are you giving on the underlying data?
- Do you have different structures for different members of the team?
- If you are doing a commission or bonus plan, make sure you think through the nuances ahead of time -
- Offer Non-Monetary Incentives: Besides monetary compensation, consider offering additional benefits like flexible schedules, professional development opportunities, or health and wellness programs to keep your team motivated and satisfied.
Compensation practices in a medspa can help you attract strong talent - and make or break your business. By understanding the pros and cons of flat fee versus commission-based compensation, and by staying informed about the legal landscape, you can build a compensation structure that motivates your staff while keeping your business compliant and thriving. Whether you choose flat fees, bonuses, or retail commissions, ensure that your approach aligns with the unique legal and operational needs of your medspa to foster long-term success.
For more information and helpful tips on running your med spa, check out these articles:
- https://optimantra.com/blog/how-to-get-more-patients-for-your-medical-practice-using-online-listings
- https://optimantra.com/blog/managing-patient-cancellations-in-a-small-independent-medical-practice
- https://optimantra.com/blog/10-proven-strategies-to-boost-patient-retention-at-your-med-spa
- https://optimantra.com/blog/building-your-business-engaging-patients-with-packages-and-recurring-memberships
- https://optimantra.com/blog/10-ways-to-improve-patient-retention-without-a-ton-of-work
A good EMR is key to running a successful med spa practice - try OptiMantra! With features specifically tailored to med spas, you’ll be able to manage your schedule and patients, retain clients, and grow your practice. Get a free trial here.
